Sweep rail

Next
 From:  all2000 (SPEEDY)
577.1 
Hi Michael,
for first thing I want give thanks to you for the last Beta.
I send you a file and an image that show a surface that I have realized with the system of scaling rail, but the result is bad and unexpected. Is this a bug or other problems?

I want ask you, if in a next future is possible to insert a command that we can use to extend the surface, because actually, if I don't wrong, the extension is used only to extend the curve and not the surface. About this command I need some information. should explain to me why if I lengthen through the tool you extend a curve which has produced a surface for instance extruded direction a other existing limit superfice the produced surface does not keep himself up to date
following curve lenghtening have tried to activate History but has not worked, Why?
Besides, about the History, can you teach me the best use of this command with the situation more complex, because now I am able to use the history with the easy situation as copy or mirror etc.....
Of course..........if you could, since I have some problem with the English language.
Could you help me understand the history command explanation well with help of some image?

Thanks for everything, also of the big patience which you show answering us

  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged

Previous
Next
 From:  Frenchy Pilou (PILOU)
577.2 In reply to 577.1 

< I have some problem with the English language
What languages do you want? :)
There are yet 3 possible in this forum :)
English Spanish French :)
About the rail : you have not make error!
Just your curves are not adapted.

A cool management can be this one
Make you sweep with 1 or 2 rail
So you can now draw the rail measure over your volume (better if it is snapped at the extremities
Select your previous volume sweep
Erase it : so you have always your curve + 1 or 2 rail and the Rail measure
Now you can make the complete Sweep + Rail Measure :)

---
Pilou
Is beautiful that please without concept!
My Gallery
  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged

Previous
 From:  Michael Gibson
577.3 In reply to 577.1 
Hi Speedy - about the scaling rail, there are 2 problems here.

First, a scaling rail should be smooth throughout, the one you have here comes to a sharp point in the middle which will probably cause a kind of strange lump in the surface at that point. If you want it to come to a sharp point there, then you will need to do the sweep in multiple pieces instead of all in one piece.

It is possible to smooth out the sharp point in your scaling rail by turning on points and then selecting and deleting the sharp point.

Then the second problem is that for the scaling rail to work well, it needs to cover the full extent of the sweep. In this case your scaling rail does not fully extend to the ends of the sweep, it stops at a point internal to the sweep.

I have illustrated that here by extending a perpendicular line along your profile - you can see that there is a gap there between that plane and the end of your scaling rail.



It is ok if your scaling rail shoots out farther than the sweep (in fact it is a good idea to go ahead and make it extend further to be safe), but if it does not cover the entire range of the sweep the sweep will revert to regular non-scaling-rail behavior in those areas.


About surface extension - I'd like to add this in the future but I'm sorry I don't think I will be able to do it in time for the 1.0 version, this will have to wait until the 2.0 version. The other way to do this right now is to construct a new surface using the edge of an existing surface as one of the curves. For example do a one-rail sweep using the edge of a surface to construct a new one that is touching it.

About extend and history - this was a bug, I have fixed it for the next beta release. So for example if you have extruded a curve and then extend the curve, in the next beta the extrusion will also update.

Is there something else that you want to know about history other than that extend bug? If so please let me know.

- Michael

  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged
 

Reply to All Reply to All