How do you make a saddle type solid?
All  1-3  4-6

Previous
Next
 From:  Michael Gibson
4400.4 In reply to 4400.1 
Hi cc,

> Apparently loft doesn't work on curved surfaces.
> Network didn't work either.

Both Loft and Network take curves (or edges) as input and build surfaces from those curves.

Since Loft or Network do not take surfaces as input if you just select an entire surface object as the input into the command it will just be ignored - you've got to select curve objects for Loft to use instead of surface objects.

You can duplicate any edge into a curve object by selecting it and doing a copy/paste (ctrl+c/ctrl+v) or also like Pilou mentions you can select a bunch of edges and use the Join command to make a new curve from them that is all joined together into one piece.

Since your objects have fairly different shaped outlines, to make a good surface in between your 2 objects there you'll need to control how things are segmented so that you have a good match between each outline - this will mean using Join and/or Trim to configure the pieces into segments that match up nicely.

- Michael
  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged

Previous
Next
 From:  Michael Gibson
4400.5 In reply to 4400.1 
Hi cc, so your smaller profile there is segmented into 8 pieces with 4 long side edges and 4 smaller rounded corner segments. So to control how those segments will match to the outer profiles, I drew in some line segments from each segment's endpoint like this:



Each of those lines goes from the end of one of the smaller curve's segment endpoints to a perpendicular snap on the larger curve. Then I trimmed that outer curve by those lines and joined together pieces, and used the Rebuild command (link) to reconstruct a few joined pieces so they were made up of one single smooth segment.

So after that rearranging, I got the outer curve to be set up to have 8 segments same as the inside curve - now when lofting each of the segments will match up in the loft so that gives you some more control over how different shaped things get connected together.

The 3DM file is attached - to loft it, select these 2 curves:



and then run Construct > Loft to build this result:




That can then be joined with your other potato chip surface pieces to make a fully closed solid.

Your objects are a little small in size, and you may see some kind of odd things that are related to that since the default fitting tolerance of 0.001 units is not a very small distance compared to your object's size - if you see things like stuff sagging away noticeably from your curves it means your objects are too small in size and try scaling them up by 10 times so that the fitting tolerance is not too large in comparison to your objects.

- Michael

  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged

Previous
 From:  cc (CCLENK)
4400.6 
Thanks, everyone! I got it to work.

It's great to have such a responsive community here.

BTW, I'm here by way of Alibre. One of the reasons I upgraded to Expert is so that I can have MOI to do these complex shapes that Alibre kept choking on.
  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged
 

Reply to All Reply to All

 

 
 
Show messages: All  1-3  4-6