Need some advice on bad geometry from NX Unigraphics
 1-4  5-24  25

Previous
 From:  shane (SHANE_W)
5870.25 In reply to 5870.18 
<<<<The import scale is a weird one. I had no idea that it was that size in MOI, and that ~4inches is right in the ballpark. Now things are even more confusing.
My reason for assuming the scales are off, is because I have a set of reliable numbers I use (for instance) for adding small bevels to certain hard edges on the products. I do enough of these products were I can count on those numbers to look right. Normally, I would use something like .1 or .25. Now, that has always worked with the ProE STEP exports I get, and they are the same products as the ones I am also now receiving from NX. But with the NX STEP file, I had to back WAY off to .001 to approximate the same edge profile.
So, I don't know what to do to figure this out.>>>>

 

Sounds like your Pro-E files were in MM and your new files from NX are in inches. A .25 fillet on a 4" part is rather large. A .25 fillet on a 102 mm part sounds like what you were doing. I don't think any weird scaling is going on with any of your files. Measure some of your old files. A .001 fillet is very close to a 1/4 of a mm.

I get quite a few files from Pro-e, solidworks, inventor etc. and all of them usually need a few things touched up. Things like the corners of fillets bad trims etc I don't think there is a perfect solution. Nothing a few rail sweeps wont fix. I would ask for .step and .iges files and you should have your bases covered.

P.S. I have played with via cad a few times and it would crash a bunch of larger CAD files. I my opinion MOI is much better. Every once in a while I use a open source program called free cad. I seems to have a very robust .iges and .stp importer and may be worth a try on some troublesome files.


-Shane
  Reply Reply More Options
Post Options
Reply as PM Reply as PM
Print Print
Mark as unread Mark as unread
Relationship Relationship
IP Logged
 

Reply to All Reply to All

 

 
 
Show messages:  1-4  5-24  25