“”””” Plasticity vs MoI””””””

Here’s my take.

Michael is a brilliant graphics student who created rhino as an enthusiastic yoot…

He created that behemoth long ago and has a compounded experience level with his entire dev-sales-lifecycle-market (insert your “what it’s really about” here)

He decided to move out on his own and “avoid all the pitfalls i created” with rhino, in his new “moment of inspiration”

He is currently succeeding!!

Nick is an intelligent kid. Full of enthusiasm. He decided to create his own product and chose some bad ass tools to do it.

It is currently in it’s infancy and has attracted users from enthusiast to advanced.

The comparison will come in 15 years when Nick can look back and ponder “rats… i should have not done that”. His product will be owned by someone else and his new project will be named “Aha!!3d”

Then 12 years into that Aha!!3d can be compared to MoI3D version 4…..

I don't like this type of post at all, also because we often talk superficially, without taking many factors into account, I have both applications and I use both as well as using FreeCAD, Blender and other various tools such as gCAD3d and FreeShip, each software has its strengths and its shortcomings, in Moi3D often, people do not know how to use it, because they do not know the basics of CAD, and this also happens with Plasticity, FreeCAD and Blender, I prefer this because it has this, or saying this sucks because it doesn't have this, is pretty corny.

Often there is the risk of making assessments on first impressions that are only the result of ignorance, and for this reason I suggest everyone to avoid making other posts with this type of topic because it is easy to fall into disputes that make no sense especially here on the Moi3D forum , I also have my favorite things in Plasticity, but Moi3D is an application that I can't do without for endless reasons, like for Blender and FreeCAD etc..

I agree, that's also why I took my time to actually learn and use Plasticity for a couple of weeks/months to have a better idea, as you can't really make your mind doodle 2 hours in it.

Talking about using 'both' I would so much love a clipboard copy functionality between the 2 softwares. I know there is hack somewhere that is using a temp file format, but it rely on a .stp and I hate that format, there is often stuff breaking during the "translation".
(.3dm would be a much better option, but Plasticity can only read it, not write :( )

Nicely put Burrman!

I agree entirely with your viewpoint....

Ditto!

Plus: pafurijaz

Who made you judge and jury? Don't partake if you don't like it, but you don't get to tell us what to think and say, sorry...

Plasticity's user interface is way too keyboard centric for me.

Once Michael updates to vers.5 with fillet problems resolved, there no reason for me to get anything else.

I can design my prototypes for 3d printing to exact scale in MoI, something that is tough to do in Plasticity.

Even worse, Plasticity displays the dimensions of a finished object, yet you can't change them via input,
making editing basically a "re-draw the object" item.

My 2 Cents worth...

It's a 1.0 release dude, what do you expect ?

I have never used that post scale editing function. Looks like it's a deal breaker for you, I understand that ... but that doesn't mean everything is "trash" ... or made by a kid with no experience that should come back in 15y from now so we could discuss :P
Time will tell how the interface will evolve, and if some back pedal is possible ... looks like there are plan to add radial menu, maybe that could help to smooth out the keyboard centric.

My first reaction when discovering Plasticity was "is this guy trying to clone MoI ?" ... but after using it, he's not :P like in some aspect I wish he would :O)

But yeah on both side I see miss information made by people who really didn't try one or the other more than 5mins, it's really odd ... but nothing new heh !

That said indie dev are pretty rare, wish we could work that out more peacefully :P

""""""""""or made by a kid with no experience that should come back in 15y from now so we could discuss """"""""""""""""

But it DOES and he IS!

The same way Michael was when he created Rhino3d....

So I agree with some others who mentioned they though this type of thread is shit.

I gave Nick "Kudo's". I equated him to MICHAEL (A huge compliment in My opinion)

And I didn't "Compare the 2 apps" either.

I pointed out my opinion about how and why the comparison is inappropriate. It actually does a disservice to NICK!

But others will just have to accept my opinion. Wont they.