Full Version: Siemens NX

From: blindfoldjump [#1]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Heya!
I thinking about purchasing a license for Siemens NX. Was wondering if anybody had any experience using it.
I love Moi but there are certain tools I miss, feel like I need a supporting software.
So far I've only found positive information about it and I guess I just wanna see if there is anything against it, besides the actual pricetag :)

This question might be more appropriate in another forum I dont know, but I always felt more at home here so I hope you dont mind a non-moi3d related topic

Cheers Nick

Reply


From: Mindset (IGNITER) [#2]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Not sure if this is useful information, but the old Alibre team is back and has acquired the software back from 3D Systems.
https://www.alibre.com/
They proclaim themselves to be 3D MCAD software for individuals and small to medium sized businesses.

Regards,
-- MindSet

Reply


From: Karsten (KMRQUS) [#3]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Hello Nick,
first - NX is a shortcut for nonsense clicks. I am working every day with NX (4 years) and compared to Catia V5 (14 years with V4/V5) the workflow needs more meters of mouse movements. Surface design isn`t intuitive - everything seems to be possible, but hunderets of switches leads to try and error. Filleting in NX super- very stable. Sketcher sometimes gives surprising results while making constrains - other companies uses the same libraries from d-cubed (surpise owened by Siemens) The surface quality is good. Sheetmetal works fine. The assemebly concept works, but seems to be developed between the first and the second world war - maybe with respect to compatibiliy. It depends on that what you want to do and what are you missing at the moment. The only software I hate more is SAP.

Have a nice day
Karsten

Reply


From: Michael Gibson [#4]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Hi Karsten, did you attend training classes when you first started with NX? It would probably be good for Nick to know whether that's pretty much required to get started or if it's not.

- Michael

Reply


From: Karsten (KMRQUS) [#5]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Hello Michael, Hello Nick,
yep, I had a training for NX (4 days) and for Catia V4 (3 weeks) and for Catia V5 no training:-) only for DigitalMockUp. I was courious to all that buttons and they did all what I wanted and what I expected.
I`ve worked also with Solidworks and Alibre/Geomagic, HiCad and AutoCAD 10-14. Integrated in Ansys is SpaceClaim since V17 - some very cool features - very useful for preprocessing simulations and a lot of exchange formats. The big advantage of NX for Companies is the PLM - but not the workflow - only the opinion of an old man.

Reply


From: Michael Gibson [#6]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Hi Karsten,

re:
> The big advantage of NX for Companies is the PLM - but not the workflow - only the opinion of an old man.

So just to clarify the PLM is stuff like organizing a potentially large number of files, having them in some kind of repository, easier sharing - basically stuff like that which involves many people working together on a project.

If it's just one single person working on a project much of that won't really be applicable is that true?

- Michael

Reply


From: Karsten (KMRQUS) [#7]
 6 Oct
To: ALL

Yes! Teamcenter - CAM-ToolChain - Change Managment/Version Managment - Material handling, interfaces to Production systems and so on... are also aspects!

Reply


From: BurrMan [#8]
 7 Oct
To: ALL

Hey nick,
It reads kindof like wanting to be helicopter dropped 30 miles off the coast of hawaii to go scuba diving...

If you are looking at siemens, Maybe you want to be looking at solid edge...

Reply


From: blindfoldjump [#9]
 9 Oct
To: ALL

Thanks alot everyone, appreciate you taking the time to answer!
I had the opportunity to try out NX for a couple of days now and I gotta say. It's certainly a great software, impressed by several of the tools. It wasnt exactly what I expected, I thought from watching youtube videos that it would feel more intuitive. Well I guess Im used to Moi :)

Hey Karsten, thanks for sharing your experience, very valuable.

Burmann: Hehe yeah burr, you might be right there. Thanks for the tip about SolidEdge.

Reply


From: Karsten (KMRQUS) [#10]
 9 Oct
To: ALL

Hello Nick,

please share your experiences and impressions after testing in more detail.

Thanks in advance!
Karsten

Reply


Reply to All

Back to thread list | Login

© 2017 Project Beehive Forum