Show messages: All
1-9
10-12
From: MajorGrubert (CARLOSFERREIRAPINTO)
I can avoid looking everyday at nonsense AI slop images made with zero effort and completely useless. Bye
From: mkdm
Thanks, Michael, for your announced intention to address this issue on the forum. I hope it helps ease the problem.
Just to be clear, I have nothing against people who use AI, or against the technology itself.
It’s a new tool, and it should be treated and appreciated as such. But people also need to know how to use it appropriately, and, above all, with a healthy dose of critical thinking.
I use AI myself in my day to day software development work, but only in very limited ways for specific tasks, and with a deep background built on a lifetime of study behind me.
Of course, everyone can do whatever they want, and that goes without saying.
Still, I have no problem saying that I don’t have much sympathy for people who, instead of putting in the effort to learn the various techniques themselves, whether modeling, rendering, drawing, or anything else, delegate nearly all their work to one or more prompts in one AI engine or another to generate renders or 3D models, without having done much of the work themselves.
And I want to repeat the central point that matters to me.
This forum and Moi 3D itself are built around learning, hands on practice, crafting what you create, and doing the actual sketching, modeling, and so on.
Drawing a couple of lines or a few polygons, then handing the model, or a screenshot, to an AI prompt to do the rest, goes against the spirit of this software and this forum. In my view, Moi 3D and this forum are for the craftspeople of computer graphics and 3D modeling!
That’s the message I want to make clear first and foremost to you, Michael, the creator of Moi 3D, and then to the other users of this wonderful forum.
And Michael, after all these years of being around here, I hope you’ll forgive me for saying this: as stellar as Moi 3D is, this forum is even bigger and more important than the software itself. Without the quality of this forum, Moi 3D would be nothing.
Best regards, and I’m looking forward to the official release of V5 :)
From: PaQ
Well I guess it's mainly Pilou posting AI useless image everywhere he can. MoI discord was constantly polluted too, I just left (it was either AI, or bot scam).
I understand the hype tho, but I was hopping more etiquette on the subject, like you don't post a AI slop after someone working his best at rendering a MoI project for example.
I don't think the intention was bad, Pilou is def a chill person that also help a lot on MoI really related stuff ...
It's pretty sad because they are way better use for those tools. I recently vibe script a little LDraw parser for MoI to import a bunch of lego bricks, nothing amazing to talk about but it saved me tons of time to rebuild a little .3dm lego library. They are some cool usage for it, anyone can now create MoI script tailored to a very specif need (instead of annoying Michael about it).
@Pilou ... rendering product is all about control, and AI is just bad at this ... but it could help to prepare a better scene setup, maybe craft some fancy shaders or material parameters for your favourite render app. But vomiting 200 random images with free banana blabla AI service (that only care about getting your email) has zero value, no one look at it, there is zero interest in this. It's like showing your kid picture to a co-worker or something.
Show messages: All
1-9
10-12