As a rule of thumb, its best to use loft loose for organic shapes.
The alternative is to create it as a subd mesh and import using Moi's v4 > subd > create tool.
re:
> I cannot filllet between the heart and the skewer - what is wrong?
There is a little tiny edge fragment in that boundary that fillet doesn't like, here:
I repaired that by using Edit > Separate, untrim (select all edges and hit delete), then using Edit > Join to glue the pieces back together.
Note that if you have pieces that contact each other along a common edge already it can be better to use Edit > Join to glue them together and not Boolean Union because Edit > Join will only glue edges to other open edges and not try to do surface/surface intersections and remove material like the booleans are focused on doing.
You should now be able to fillet the repaired version (attached .3dm file) with a radius of 0.8 or lower.
Michael and folks, thxalo—I tried connecting it, but it didn't connect. I'm adding the workflow for the solution to my local MOI3d wiki. I'm getting close. And—all of your hearts look better than mine. I'm going to try rebuilding it, incorporating your suggestions. I think it needs to be thicker at the top when viewed from the side. Thanks everyone—I'll be in touch... cheers...