MoI discussion forum
MoI discussion forum

Full Version: Fillet not working well

From: Ironice
28 Mar 2023   [#1]
Hi Michael,

have a problem with a simple thing.
A result of filleting in MOI. Two spheres with union boolean.
The max. fillet working radius is 4mm. Above 4mm fails.

Blue Spheres from MOI.
Gray Spheres are from Fusion360.

Is it a bug ?









Image Attachments:
moi_fillet_01.jpg  moi_fillet_03.jpg 


From: Michael Gibson
28 Mar 2023   [#2] In reply to [#1]
Hi Ironice, yes it's a bug in the geometry library that MoI uses. Can you please post the .3dm file with the spheres in it so I can see if I can get it fixed up?

Thanks, - Michael
From: Ironice
28 Mar 2023   [#3] In reply to [#2]
The base File for you.

Attachments:
MW_bubbles_turn_tmp_michael.3dm


From: Michael Gibson
28 Mar 2023   [#4] In reply to [#3]
Hi Ironice, thanks for the file. One way that will work in the current MoI version is if you select the 2 spheres while they are separate objects without booleaning them together and then run the Fillet command.

That will do a surface/surface fillet instead of an edge based fillet and then use Edit > Join to glue the pieces together.

But I'll see if I can get the edge based fillet working too.

Thanks, - Michael
From: Ironice
28 Mar 2023   [#5] In reply to [#4]
Hah, very nice. Thanks Michael.

A working Edge based Fillet would be more elegant, of course.
With edge Fillet you can vary the rounding so nicely.

Ersin
From: Ironice
29 Mar 2023   [#6]
Hi Michael,

is there a way to snap an solid on the midpoint of a surface?



Image Attachments:
moi_fillet_04.jpg 


From: Frenchy Pilou (PILOU)
29 Mar 2023   [#7] In reply to [#6]
User the Helper Lines! ;)

Click without release, Move, release
This can be made after call a function, before the first click of this function, after the first click and before the last click of the function!


From: Frenchy Pilou (PILOU)
29 Mar 2023   [#8]
When you will have a good training of Helper Lines
you will can open the little white trapeze for more options! ;)
Who appears when you release the mouse button drawing an helper lines!
Alas don't appears on my recording system! :(


From: Charlie (BLARBLES)
29 Mar 2023   [#9] In reply to [#1]
If you rotate the edges on the two balls to be away from the fillet then the fillet will be successful (at least in MOI5 beta)

Image Attachments:
Screenshot 2023-03-29 at 10.13.14 AM.png 


From: Ironice
29 Mar 2023   [#10]
Thanks for your answer Pilou.

There was a small mistake on my part.
The circle was not exactly round. Therefore, the center was not exactly in the middle of the circle.
I knew that with the helplines. ;)

Thanks anyway.
From: Frenchy Pilou (PILOU)
29 Mar 2023   [#11] In reply to [#9]
Yes the curves generator generate some troubles! It's a good habit to separate them!
From: Frenchy Pilou (PILOU)
29 Mar 2023   [#12]
You can also use the script of Max Smirnov for find the Center of Gravity! ;)
(just make some thickness to your surface! ;)

https://moi3d.com/download/scripts/max/CVolume.v.3.0.2022.05.24.zip