Why does this Boolean Difference not create solids?

 From:  chippwalters
7039.1 
Just bought MoI. Woo-Woo!

When I subtract this "parting line" solid from the larger widget solid, the resulting object is hollow. Why is this? How do I fix? (Newbie issue).

Here's a link to the file:
https://altuit.cloud/web/dbpub/3D/booleanProb.3dm

Thanks!

EDITED: 18 Nov 2014 by CHIPPWALTERS

Image Attachments:
Size: 582.7 KB, Downloaded: 64 times, Dimensions: 800x1442px