| Keith, 
I brought your model into KeyShot and it looks really smooth.  I don't see any anomalies anywhere.
 
I'll have to defer to the experts as to why it doesn't render well in your program.
 
Your loft looks pretty close to the SubD version.  I tried lofts before Max's scripts were available.  I'd say making changes to the SubD structure is a lot faster (for me anyway).
 
Hopefully someone will have an answer for the render issue you're having.
 
Ed Ferguson
  |