Help me.. the Batwings will not go away!!!

After every session, I check "Mark as Read" -Visible discussions- and all the threads become hidden.

Yet, without fail, the next time I log in, Batwings is back up at the top of the list!
And there's never anything new about them that should make them come back.

I have nothing against Batwings or the people who like them,
I just don't want to see them every time!

Is it me? Am I doing something wrong? :-)

Jesse