Seems like a bug to me....

 From:  JTB
1673.5 
The reason I did this, was that I needed to make an extruded curve, thinner... The solid was already rotated.So I copied it downwards half it's width and I tried to subtract.
Anyway, of course there is an easy workaround

Here's the 3dm file
***Modeling Of Ideas***
Attachments: